Barstow's Dairy Store and Bakery logo image

Barstow's Dairy Store and Bakery


Bagels, English Muffins, & Toast

Bagel with Butter

Your choice of bagel toasted with Cabot butter

$3.15

English Muffin

English muffin toasted with nothing on it

$2.10

English Muffin with Butter

English muffin toasted with Cabot butter

$2.60

Grilled Muffin

Grilled on our panini machine and slathered with Cabot butter

$3.35

Bagels

Not toasted, not cut

$2.20

Bagel with Cream Cheese

Your choice of bagel toasted with cream cheese

$3.65

Half & Half

Pick 2

Select 1 Half Sandwich and 1 soup, green salad, or mac & cheese

$11.50

Sandwiches

Includes a pickle on the side

Garden Sandwich

Hummus, Cabot cheddar cheese, crisp cucumber, tomato, shredded carrot, fresh red peppers, & red onion on a wheat wrap, served with a pickle on the side

$11.50

BLT

Your choice of bread, toasted, with lettuce, tomato, bacon, and mayo, served with a pickle on the side

$11.50

Uncle Fuzzy

Multi-grain bread, roast beef, horseradish cheddar cheese, horseradish mayo, lettuce, tomato, and red onion, served with a pickle on the side

$11.50

Shermanator

A Barstow's favorite! Wheat bread, turkey, ham, bacon, Cabot cheddar cheese, mayo, lettuce, and tomato, served with a pickle on the side

$12.30

Build Your Own Sandwich

Your choice of bread, meat, cheese, sauce, and toppings. Automatically comes with lettuce, tomato, and red onion and a pickle on the side.

$11.50

Il Presidente

Ham, pepperoni, salami, Cabot provolone cheese, black olives, banana peppers, tomato, salt & pepper, oil & vinegar grilled on Ciabatta, served with a pickle on the side

$13.30

Spicy Chicken

Housemade shredded spicy chicken, tomato, spinach, Cabot cheddar cheese, and Chipotle mayo on a sun-dried tomato wrap, served with a pickle on the side

$12.30

Farmhand

Wheat bread, turkey, Cabot cheddar cheese, crunchy apple slices, and Dijon mustard, served with a pickle on the side

$11.50

Kelly Girl

Our most popular sandwich! Turkey, bacon, Cabot cheddar cheese, ranch dressing, tomato, red onion, and avocado grilled in a sun-dried tomato wrap, served with a pickle on the side

$13.00

Pioneer

Thanksgiving in a sandwich: turkey, stuffing, cranberry sauce, spinach, and red onion grilled on Ciabatta, served with a pickle on the side

$13.30

Chicken Salad Sandwich

Our housemade chicken salad on your choice of bread and Cabot cheese with lettuce, tomato, and onion, served with a pickle on the side

$12.30

Barstownian

Ham and Cabot Swiss with honey mustard, lettuce, and tomato on rye. Served with a pickle on the side.

$11.50

Cheese Griller

Your choice of bread and Cabot cheese grilled on our panini machine, served with a pickle on the side

$10.50

Soups

Soups come with oyster crackers and a spoon

Cup Barstow's Famous Chili

served with oyster crackers

$4.85

Cup Soup of the Day

served with oyster crackers

$4.85

Bowl Soup of the Day

served with two packages of oyster crackers

$6.95

Cup Tomato Cheddar Soup

served with oyster crackers

$4.85

Quart Tomato Cheddar Soup

$12.00

Bowl Barstow's Famous Chili

served with two packages of oyster crackers

$6.95

Bowl Tomato Cheddar Soup

served with two packages of oyster crackers

$6.95

Quart Soup of the Day

$12.00

Quart Barstow's Famous Chili

$12.00

Quart New England Clam Chowder

$12.00

Green Salads

Salads come with dressing packet and a fork

Large Green Salad

Lettuce, spinach, arugula, tomato, red onion, green pepper, cucumber, carrots served with your choice of dressing on the side

$9.50

Small Green Salad

Lettuce, spinach, arugula, tomato, red onion, green pepper, cucumber, carrots served with your choice of dressing on the side

$7.25

Chef Salad

Lettuce, spinach, tomato, onion, cucumber, green pepper, shredded Cabot cheddar cheese, ham, turkey, carrots, hard boiled egg and your choice of dressing on the side

$12.50

Mac & Cheese & More

Cup Mac & Cheese

Our homemade Cabot mac & cheese! | 8oz

$4.85

Bowl Mac & Cheese

Our homemade Cabot mac & cheese! | 16oz

$6.95

Bag of Chips

Deep River Chips | 2oz bag

$1.90

Kid's Menu

Kid Whole Turkey & Cheese

Turkey and cheese on white or wheat bread with Cabot American cheese

$6.25

Kid Whole PB&J

Classic PB&J on white or wheat bread

$6.50

Kid 1/2 Grilled Cheese

Grilled cheese on white or wheat bread with Cabot American cheese

$4.25

Kid's Plate

Select 5 items to build out the perfect lunch!

$7.00

Kid 1/2 PB&J

Classic PB&J on white or wheat bread

$4.75

Kid Whole Ham & Cheese

Ham and cheese on white or wheat bread with Cabot American cheese

$6.25

Kid 1/2 Turkey & Cheese

Turkey and cheese on white or wheat bread with Cabot American cheese

$4.50

Kid 1/2 Ham and Cheese

Ham and cheese on white or wheat bread with Cabot American cheese

$4.50

Kid Whole Grilled Cheese

Grilled cheese on white or wheat bread with Cabot American cheese

$6.00

Kid Toast

White toast with butter

$2.50

1/2 Kid Toast

White toast with butter

$2.00

Coffee & Tea

Hot Chocolate

Swiss Miss hot cocoa with hot water | 16oz

$2.45

Hot Tea

16oz

$2.60

Small Hot Coffee

12oz

$2.58

Iced Tea

Unsweeted black iced tea made in house | 20oz

$3.65

Hot Chai Tea

Vanilla Spiced Chai Tea | 16oz

$3.55

Large Hot Coffee

20oz

$3.58

Iced Coffee

20oz

$2.88

Medium Hot Coffee

16oz

$3.08

Beverages

OJ with Ice

Fresh squeezed! | 20oz

$2.60

Arnold Palmer

Half unsweetened iced tea, half fresh squeezed lemonade | 20oz

$3.65

Bottled Beverages

Nantucket Nectar

$2.85

Polar Seltzer

$2.25

Arizona Teas

$1.00

Small Milk

From Mapleline Farm, Hadley, MA

$1.90

Flavor Water

$1.85

Pierce Brother's Fogbuster Nitro Cold Brew Coffee

$4.50

Pierce Brother's Nitro Vanilla Cold Brew Coffee

$4.50

Vitamin Water

$2.85

Gatorade

$2.85

Poland Spring Water

$1.85

Kombucha

$3.25

Smoothies & Milkshakes

Milkshake

Made with McCray's milk and your choice of Maple Valley Creamery ice cream | 20oz

$6.75

Coffee Float

Your choice of Maple Valley Creamery ice cream with iced coffee poured over the top | 20oz

$5.15

Smoothie

Build your perfect smoothie! | 20oz

$7.00

Quake

A milkshake with Maple Valley Creamery ice cream and iced coffee | 20oz

$6.75

Pies / Whole

Coconut Cream Pie

$20.00

Key Lime Pie

$20.00

Peach Pie

$22.00

Apple Crumb

$2.86

Peanutbutter Pie

$22.00

Blueberry Pie

$24.00

Chocolate Pecan

$24.00

Choc. Cream Pie

$20.00

Apple Pie

$20.00

Banana Cream Pie

$20.00

Minced Meat Pie

$20.00

Mixed Berry whl

$22.00

Cherry Pie

$19.00

Lemon Merangue

$22.00

Pecan Pie

$23.00

Pumpkin Pie

$20.00