Bagels, English Muffins, & Toast
Bagels
Not toasted, not cut
$2.10
Bagel with Butter
Your choice of bagel toasted with Cabot butter
$3.00
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Your choice of bagel toasted with cream cheese
$3.50
English Muffin with Butter
English muffin toasted with Cabot butter
$2.50
English Muffin
English muffin toasted with nothing on it
$2.00
Grilled Muffin
Grilled on our panini machine and slathered with Cabot butter
$2.90
Half & Half
Pick 2
Select 1 Half Sandwich and 1 soup, green salad, or mac & cheese
$10.00
Sandwiches
Includes a pickle on the side
Build Your Own Sandwich
Your choice of bread, meat, cheese, sauce, and toppings. Automatically comes with lettuce, tomato, and red onion and a pickle on the side.
$9.70
Barstownian
Ham and Cabot Swiss with honey mustard, lettuce, and tomato on rye. Served with a pickle on the side.
$9.70
BLT
Your choice of bread, toasted, with lettuce, tomato, bacon, and mayo, served with a pickle on the side
$9.70
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Our housemade chicken salad on your choice of bread and Cabot cheese with lettuce, tomato, and onion, served with a pickle on the side
$9.70
Farmhand
Wheat bread, turkey, Cabot cheddar cheese, crunchy apple slices, and Dijon mustard, served with a pickle on the side
$9.70
Garden Sandwich
Hummus, Cabot cheddar cheese, crisp cucumber, tomato, shredded carrot, fresh red peppers, & red onion on a wheat wrap, served with a pickle on the side
$9.70
Shermanator
A Barstow's favorite! Wheat bread, turkey, ham, bacon, Cabot cheddar cheese, mayo, lettuce, and tomato, served with a pickle on the side
$10.50
Uncle Fuzzy
Multi-grain bread, roast beef, horseradish cheddar cheese, horseradish mayo, lettuce, tomato, and red onion, served with a pickle on the side
$9.70
Cheese Griller
Your choice of bread and Cabot cheese grilled on our panini machine, served with a pickle on the side
$8.70
Il Presidente
Ham, pepperoni, salami, Cabot provolone cheese, black olives, banana peppers, tomato, salt & pepper, oil & vinegar grilled on Ciabatta, served with a pickle on the side
$11.50
Kelly Girl
Our most popular sandwich! Turkey, bacon, Cabot cheddar cheese, ranch dressing, tomato, red onion, and avocado grilled in a sun-dried tomato wrap, served with a pickle on the side
$11.20
Spicy Chicken
Housemade shredded spicy chicken, tomato, spinach, Cabot cheddar cheese, and Chipotle mayo on a sun-dried tomato wrap, served with a pickle on the side
$10.50
Soups
Soups come with oyster crackers and a spoon
Bowl Tomato Cheddar Soup
served with two packages of oyster crackers
$6.70
Bowl Barstow's Famous Chili
served with two packages of oyster crackers
$6.70
Bowl New England Clam Chowder
served with two packages of oyster crackers
$6.70
Bowl Soup of the Day
served with two packages of oyster crackers
$6.70
Cup Tomato Cheddar Soup
served with oyster crackers
$4.65
Cup Barstow's Famous Chili
served with oyster crackers
$4.65
Cup New England Clam Chowder
served with oyster crackers
$4.65
Cup Soup of the Day
served with oyster crackers
$4.65
Quart Barstow's Famous Chili
$11.29
Quart New England Clam Chowder
$11.29
Quart Soup of the Day
$11.29
Quart Tomato Cheddar Soup
$11.29
Green Salads
Salads come with dressing packet and a fork
Chef Salad
Lettuce, spinach, tomato, onion, cucumber, green pepper, shredded Cabot cheddar cheese, ham, turkey, carrots, hard boiled egg and your choice of dressing on the side
$11.50
Large Green Salad
Lettuce, spinach, arugula, tomato, red onion, green pepper, cucumber, carrots served with your choice of dressing on the side
$8.40
Small Green Salad
Lettuce, spinach, arugula, tomato, red onion, green pepper, cucumber, carrots served with your choice of dressing on the side
$6.50
Mac & Cheese & More
Bag of Chips
Deep River Chips | 2oz bag
$1.80
Cup Mac & Cheese
Our homemade Cabot mac & cheese! | 8oz
$4.65
Bowl Mac & Cheese
Our homemade Cabot mac & cheese! | 16oz
$6.70
Kid's Menu
1/2 Kid Toast
White toast with butter
$1.75
Kid Toast
White toast with butter
$3.20
Kid 1/2 Grilled Cheese
Grilled cheese on white or wheat bread with Cabot American cheese
$4.05
Kid Whole Grilled Cheese
Grilled cheese on white or wheat bread with Cabot American cheese
$5.85
Kid 1/2 Ham and Cheese
Ham and cheese on white or wheat bread with Cabot American cheese
$4.15
Kid Whole Ham & Cheese
Ham and cheese on white or wheat bread with Cabot American cheese
$5.95
Kid 1/2 Turkey & Cheese
Turkey and cheese on white or wheat bread with Cabot American cheese
$4.15
Kid Whole Turkey & Cheese
Turkey and cheese on white or wheat bread with Cabot American cheese
$5.95
Kid 1/2 PB&J
Classic PB&J on white or wheat bread
$4.30
Kid Whole PB&J
Classic PB&J on white or wheat bread
$6.05
Kid's Plate
Select 5 items to build out the perfect lunch!
$6.60
Coffee & Tea
Small Hot Coffee
12oz
$2.55
Medium Hot Coffee
16oz
$3.05
Large Hot Coffee
20oz
$3.55
Iced Coffee
20oz
$2.85
Iced Tea
Unsweeted black iced tea made in house | 20oz
$3.50
Hot Tea
16oz
$2.50
Hot Chai Tea
Vanilla Spiced Chai Tea | 16oz
$3.50
Hot Chocolate
Swiss Miss hot cocoa with hot water | 16oz
$2.35
Beverages
Arnold Palmer
Half unsweetened iced tea, half fresh squeezed lemonade | 20oz
$3.50
Fresh Squeezed Lemonade
Fresh squeezed! | 20oz
$3.50
OJ with Ice
Fresh squeezed! | 20oz
$2.50
Bottled Beverages
Small Milk
From Mapleline Farm, Hadley, MA
$1.85
Gatorade
$2.70
Kombucha
$3.00
Nantucket Nectar
$2.70
Arizona Teas
$1.00
Flavor Water
$1.79
Poland Spring Water
$1.79
Polar Seltzer
$2.15
Vitamin Water
$2.70
Pierce Brother's Nitro Vanilla Cold Brew Coffee
$4.35
Pierce Brother's Fogbuster Nitro Cold Brew Coffee
$4.35
Smoothies & Milkshakes
Smoothie
Build your perfect smoothie! | 20oz
$6.75
Milkshake
Made with McCray's milk and your choice of Maple Valley Creamery ice cream | 20oz
$6.50
Quake
A milkshake with Maple Valley Creamery ice cream and iced coffee | 20oz
$6.50
Coffee Float
Your choice of Maple Valley Creamery ice cream with iced coffee poured over the top | 20oz
$5.10