Picked For You
Baja Fish Tacos
Four Flour tortillas filled with fresh mahi , lettuce, tomatoes, black beans and Baja Slaw. Includes a side of Pico de Gallo$25.00
6oz House Build Your Own Burger
Our famous certified angus burger topped with lettuce, tomato, and pickle$11.50
Island Drunken Shrimp
Eight jumbo shrimp, pan seared and topped with a Golden Butter Rum Sauce. Served over a bed of Island Grill rice with roasted corn. (no sides)$25.00
Wam Bam Shrimp
Crispy fried Land shark shrimp tossed in our wam bam sauced with scallions$16.00
Double Bacon Cheeseburger
Includes your choice of cheese and 4 strips of juicy bacon layered between two 6 oz certified Angus beef patties. Served with crispy fries$17.99
Coconut Shrimp
4 jumbo fried sweet coconut shrimp serve with sweet n sour dip$17.00
Calamari Rings
Crispy battered calamari rings deep fried and served with homemade marinara sauce$17.00
Coconut Shrimp
4 jumbo fried sweet coconut shrimp serve with sweet n sour dip$17.00
Cheese Bites
Fried Wisconsin Mozzarella cheese curds served with marinara$11.99
Clam Strips
Half pound of crispy clam strips served with tartar sauce or cocktail sauce$14.00
Onion Rings
Half pound of golden crispy beer battered onions rings with marinara$10.00
Steak Egg Rolls
Lightly seasoned crispy fried egg rolls, filled with tender juicy Philly cheese steak and cheese.$15.00
Wam Bam Shrimp
Crispy fried Land shark shrimp tossed in our wam bam sauced with scallions$16.00
Island Grill's Big Dill
Breaded fried gourmet dill pickle spears with sauce$11.00
Chicken Tenders
Jumbo chicken tenders lightly fried served with choice of honey mustard or BBQ sauce$16.00
Sweet n Salty Sweet Potato Waffle Fries
Fried sweet potato waffle cut fries topped with caramel syrup and sprinkled with Mediterranean sea-salt$10.99
Island Wings (12)
12 Lightly breaded and fried x-large wings, choice of mild, hot, sweet chili bbq., Old Bay, Cajun, Korean BBQ, Jamaican Jerk, or bbq. sauce$14.00
Mussels in a Red Sauce
$16.00
Cowboy Burger
Twin 6oz burger topped with Haystack onions, BBQ sauce and Cheddar cheese. Served with crispy fries$17.99
Double Bacon Cheeseburger
Includes your choice of cheese and 4 strips of juicy bacon layered between two 6 oz certified Angus beef patties. Served with crispy fries$17.99
6oz House Build Your Own Burger
Our famous certified angus burger topped with lettuce, tomato, and pickle$11.50
California Veggie Burger
Veggie patty served with lettuce, tomato, and pickle on a gourmet bun. Served with French fries$13.00
Stuffed Cheese Burger
Grilled sour dough bread stuffed with cooper cheese, caramelized onions, and applewood bacon. Includes fries No substitutions$14.00
Coconut Shrimp 12 piece Bucket
12 jumbo hand breaded coconut fried shrimp, 2 orders fries, 2 Cole slaw. Includes sweet n sour sauce on side$49.00
1 Pound fried flounder
1 Pound of hand breaded fried flounder. includes choice of tarter and or cocktail sauce$28.00
2.5lb Fried Flounder
1 Pound of hand breaded fried flounder. includes choice of tarter and or cocktail sauce$45.00
Bucke A 16 Large Fried Shrimp
16 large Shrimp. 2 orders fries and 2 sides Cole slaw . Tarter and or cocktail sauce on the side$35.00
Bucket (B) 24 Large Fried Shrimp
24 large Shrimp. 3 orders fries and 3 sides Cole slaw . Tarter and or cocktail sauce on the side$49.00
Bucket D (10) Chicken Tenders
10 chicken tenders, 2 orders fries and 3 apple sauce. Choice of honey mustard and or BBQ sauce$25.50
Bucket E (15) Chicken Tenders
15 Chicken tenders, 3 orders fries 4 apple sauce. Choice of honey mustard and or apple sauce on the side$32.50
Bucket 25 chicken tenders
25 Chicken tenders, 5 orders French fries and 5 sides apple sauce choice of honey mustard and or BBQ sauce$48.50
20 Jumbo Wings
20 jumbo wings -choice of sauce mild sauce, old bay, cajun, hot sauce, sweet chili bbq, bbq. sauce,$27.00
Captain's Platter
Fried Seafood combination -large sautéed crab cake, fried flounder, 4 jumbo shrimp, 4 fried local day scallops. Includes choice of salad and fries and Cole slaw$42.00
Coconut Shrimp (6)
6 jumbo hand dipped coconut shrimp served with sweet and sour sauce.$29.00
Fried Flounder
Fresh hand-breaded flounder includes a choice of sauce$27.00
Fried Scallops
Local day boat jersey scallops lightly breaded served with your choice of sauce.$38.00
Fried Shrimp
8 hand breaded large shrimp.$25.00
Alaskan Cod Basket
Lager battered cod, served over a bed of french fries with fresh coleslaw. Includes your choice of a garden or Caesar salad$24.00
Broiled Crab Imperial
Our homemade broiled jumbo lump crab imperial.$46.00
Mini Combo
Fresh local Cape May scallops with jumbo shrimp and flounder broiled in our white wine, butter, and lemon juice mixture.$38.00
Seafood Supreme
A great sampling of the sea, Cape May Scallops, Crab cake Stuffed shrimp, and flounder.$45.00
Ultimate Combo
Twin 4 oz cold water lobster tails, four jumbo stuffed shrimp with crab imperial, 4 large day boat scallops, flounder$84.00
Broiled Shrimp (8)
8 broiled shrimp$23.00
Ocean Trio
Six large shrimp, 4oz Maine Lobster tail, local scallops, served with drawn butter$49.00
Shrimp & Lobster Combo
6 broiled large shrimp with a 4 oz cold water lobster tail$37.00
Crabcake & Lobster Combo
$47.00
Snow Crab Clusters
Over a pound and a half of sweet queen crab. Served with drawn butter$48.00
Baja Fish Tacos
Four Flour tortillas filled with fresh mahi , lettuce, tomatoes, black beans and Baja Slaw. Includes a side of Pico de Gallo$25.00
Island Drunken Shrimp
Eight jumbo shrimp, pan seared and topped with a Golden Butter Rum Sauce. Served over a bed of Island Grill rice with roasted corn. (no sides)$25.00
Lemon Garlic Scallops
Pan seared local day boat scallops atop a lemon beurre blanc sauce with a hint of garlic$38.00
Sauteed Crab Cakes (1)
Single house-made sauteed crab cake.$27.00
Sauteed Crab Cakes (2)
2 house-made sauteed crab cakes.$42.00
Maple Pecan Salmon
Pecan crusted Jail Island Salmon, baked with a maple glaze$33.00
Cedar Plank Salmon
Oven baked salmon on a charred cedar plank served with a side of hot pepper peach bourbon sauce$33.00
Gluten Free Crab Cakes
2 pan seared crab cakes served with Tartar sauce and cocktail Includes choice of garden or Caesar salad and one side dish$31.00
Black & White Ahi Tuna
Pan-seared 10 oz Ahi Tuna with Black and White Sesame Seeds. Chef recommended medium-rare. Served with a Japanese dipping sauce$29.00
COD Salmon Jail
Jail Island Salmon has a light mild delicate flavor with a smooth buttery texture, also rich in Omega 3 and Fatty Acids. Sustainably raised in the cold, clean waters off the East Coast of Canada, in their native waters$32.00
COD Scallops
Scallops have a delicate but distinct flavor that is often described as slightly sweet and buttery. This unique taste comes from the scallop's high levels of glycogen, which is converted to glucose when the scallop is cooked.$34.00
COD Fluke Broiled
Fluke also known as Flounder is a flat lean fish, caught in clear inshore waters. Fluke has a sweet taste with a light flaky white meat.$35.00
COD Orange Roughy
$28.00
COD Halibut
$36.00
COD Ahi Tuna
Ahi Tuna has a mild, meaty flavor with firm, large flakes and is delicious seared and prepared “blackened” with cajun seasonings, or grilled, broiled$28.00
Grilled Chicken Breast
One grilled chicken breast served with your choice of seasoning. Includes choice of salad and one side dish$19.50
Double Grilled Chicken Breast
Two all-natural grilled chicken breasts served with your choice of seasoning.$25.00
12 oz Prime NY Strip
12 oz NY strip cut of grass fed beef finished with carrots(eaten by the cows) for a less earthy flavor. Steak Sauce add-ons $2 each: Fig Jam, Goat Cheese Butter, Herb Butter, Truffle Butter Fried mushrooms, fried onions. Haystack onion $3$43.00
Filet Mignon
8 oz Tender cut USDA Prime Filet Mignon. Choice of one side dish Steak Sauce add-ons $2 each: Fig Jam, Goat Cheese Butter, Herb Butter, Truffle Butter Fried mushrooms, fried onions. Haystack onion $3$43.00
Surf N Turf
USDA choice fillet mignon, broiled 4 oz cold water lobster tail, drawn butter.$59.00
Twin Surf N Turf
USDA choice fillet mignon, broiled 4 oz cold water lobster tail, drawn butter. (Twin tails)$76.00
Honey Garlic Chicken
Grilled chicken with a honey garlic glaze on a bed of island rice and broccoli$23.00
1/2 Tray Garden Salad
$16.00
1/2 Tray Island Rice
$13.00
1/2 Tray Maple Salmon
$85.00
1/2 Tray Mixed Vegetables
$13.00
6 Baked Potatoes Tray
$16.00
Pound Cole Slaw
$4.50
Family Style Fire Potatoes
cooked in beef tallow$15.00
Whole Key Lime Pie
$22.00
1/2 Tray Caesar Salad
$16.00
Family Yukon Gold Mash Tray
$15.00
Chicken Parm 1/2 Tray serves 6
$65.00
Pulled pork Tray 1/2
$60.00
A La Carte Applesauce
$2.00
A La Carte Baked Potato
$3.00
A La Carte Crab Cake
$22.00
A La Carte Fries (not gf)
fries cooked in beef tallow$3.85
A La Carte Guacamole
$3.00
A La Carte Island Rice (not gf)
$3.00
A La Carte Mandarin Oranges
$2.00
A La Carte Pico de Gallo
$1.75
A La Carte baby fire Potato
cooked in beef tallow$3.00
A La Carte Side Sour Cream
$1.50
A La Carte Slaw
$2.00
A La Carte Veggie
$3.00
Sweet Potato Waffle Fries
Side of cross cut fried sweet potato fries$7.99
Carte Lobster Tail
$23.00
A la Carte Yukon Gold Mashed Potato
$2.75
Shrimp & Corn Small
$6.00
Shrimp & Corn Medium
$10.00
Shrimp & Corn Large
$20.00
Lobster Bisque Medium
$12.00
Lobster Bisque Small
$7.00
NE Clam Small
$5.00
NE Clam Medium
$9.00
Lobster Bisque Large
$21.00
NE Clam Large
$17.00
Fiji Bottle
$2.50
San Pellergrino 16oz - bottle
$2.75
Apple Juice Box
$1.50
Fruit Punch Juice Box
$1.50
To Go Coffee 12oz
$1.50
Liquid Death Death Island
$3.00
Jarritos Orange Soda
$3.00
20oz Starry
$2.50
Poppi Strawberry Lemon Soda 12 oz
Poppi prebiotic Soda$3.00
Poppi Raspberry Rose 12 oz Can
Poppi Prebiotic Soda$3.00
Alani Cotton Candy
$3.50
Alani Cherry Slush
$3.50
Poppi Cherry Limeade 12 oz Soda
$2.50
Alani Orange Vibe
$3.50
Alani Blue Slush
$3.50
Celsius Peach Vibe
$3.50
Celsius Tropical Vibe Can
$3.50
Island Grill's Homemade Key Lime Pie
Our own homemade Key Lime Pie, served super cold, super sweet and tart$6.50
Gluten Free Key Lime Pie
$7.00
Donut Holes
10 Fried cinnamon sugar donut holes$3.50
Peanut Butter Explosion GF
Chocolate candy bar bottom topped with peanut butter ganache and chocolate mousse. Enrobed in chocolate ganache and topped with chopped peanuts( Gluten Free)$7.99
Flourless Chocolate Torte
Gluten free$7.99
Mango Strawberry Cake
Vanilla cake, layered with mango and strawberry mousse, surrounded by pink and white chocolate curls and a mango rosette$7.99
Tartufo
$4.00
Chocolate Mountain Mousse Cake
$7.99
Pint Mint Chocolate Chip ICE Cream
$6.50
Pint Salted Caramel Ice Cream
$6.50
Pint Coffee Cold Brew Ice Cream
$6.50
Pint Cookie Dough Ice Cream
$6.50
Pint Vanilla Bean Ice Cream
$6.50
Pint Strawberry Ice Cream
$6.50
Pint Pumpkin Spice Ice Cream
$6.50
Carni Double Double
Double Bacon Patties, 4 strips bacon, aged cheddar cheese, twin 6oz beef patties, redmond salt$14.00
Carni NY Strip Steak & Shrimp
12oz grass fed carrot finished New York strip Steak, 4 grilled shrimp, topped with grass fed cow butter$43.00
Grilled Salmon & Filet
Grilled Jail Island Salmon and grilled 8 oz Filet Mignon topped with grass fed cow butter. No sides and Salad$48.00
Carni Twin Chickens
2 - 8 oz grilled chicken breasts, 4 slices of bacon, add cheddar cheese $2. No sides or salad$17.00
Blacken Salmon with Lemon Caper Butter
Blacken Grilled Jail Island Salmon topped with lemon caper hotel butter$27.00
Kids Baked Salmon
$15.99
Kids Burger
$10.99
Kids Dino Nuggets
$8.99
Kids Fish n Chips
Must choose fries if you want the chips portion$11.99
Kids Grill Cheese
$7.50
Kids Grilled Chicken
$7.99
Kids Grilled Shrimp
$10.99
Kids Hot Dog
$7.00
Kids Mac Bites
$9.99
Kids Quesadilla
$8.99
Kids Cheese Pizza
$9.99
Kids Chicken Quesadilla
$13.99
BBQ Chicken Quesadilla
Grilled chicken breast diced then topped with a four blend cheese and our BBQ. sauce. Served with a side of homemade Pico de Gallo$15.00
Plain Quesadilla
One stuffed tortilla with our four cheese blend. Includes side of Pico de Gallo$9.00
Chicken Quesadilla
Grilled chicken and our 4 cheese blend stuffed into a grilled tortilla. Served with Pico de Gallo on the side$14.00
Wam Bam Quesadilla
Beer battered fried shrimp, Wam Bam Sauce, scallions, 4 cheese blend, pico de gallo$18.00
Prime Rib Quesadilla
Tender chopped Philly steaks and sautéed onions with our four cheese blend. Served with a side of pico-de-gallo$20.00
Pulled Pork Quesadilla
Our own house smoked pulled pork, shredded then stuffed into a BBQ and cheese quesadilla with a side of Pico de Gallo. No sides or salad$15.00
Backyard BLT Salad
Crisp Romaine and ice burg mix, fresh grape tomatoes, applewood bacon, sliced avocado, garlic parmesan croutons, served with chunky bleu cheese dressing$14.00
Jamaican Me Crazy Salad
Grilled all natural Jamaican Jerk Seasoned chicken over a garden salad with mango chunks, strawberries and black beans. Served with a side of Caribbean Mango vinaigrette$19.00
Buffalo Chicken Tender Salad
Sliced buffalo chicken tenders served on a garden salad in a tortilla shell served with your choice of dressing$16.00
The Sea Wedge
6 large grilled shrimp, iceberg wedge, topped with goat cheese, tomatoes, red pickled onions, caribbean mango dressing, bacon$19.00
Wam Bam Salad
Fried wam bam shrimp, garden salad, mandarin oranges, candied nuts, craisins, scallions, caribbean mango vinaigrette dressing.$19.00
Grill Chicken Caesar Salad
Grilled Chicken over a bed of romaine lettuce served with a creamy Caesar dressing, croutons and Parmesan cheese. Includes garlic bread.$16.00
Grilled Salmon Caesar Salad
Grilled Salmon over a bed of romaine lettuce served with a creamy Caesar dressing, croutons and Parmesan cheese. Includes garlic bread. Or choose a garden salad with your choice of dressing on the side$23.00
Grilled Shrimp Caesar Salad
Grilled Shrimp over a bed of romaine lettuce served with a creamy Caesar dressing, croutons and Parmesan cheese. Includes garlic bread. Or choose a garden salad with your choice of dressing on the side$18.00
Large Caesar Salad
A bed of romaine lettuce served with a creamy Caesar dressing, croutons and Parmesan cheese. Includes garlic bread.$10.00
Large Garden Salad
A bed of garden salad, croutons and Parmesan cheese. Includes garlic bread. Served with your choice of dressing$8.50
Grilled Shrimp Garden Salad
Grilled Shrimp over a bed of garden salad, croutons and Parmesan cheese. Includes garlic bread.$18.00
Grilled Chicken Garden
Grilled Chicken over a bed of garden salad, croutons and Parmesan cheese. Includes garlic bread. Served with your choice of dressing$16.00
Grilled Salmon Garden Salad
Grilled Salmon over a bed of garden salad, croutons and Parmesan cheese. Includes garlic bread. Served with your choice of dressing$23.00
Small Caesar Salad
bed of romaine lettuce served with a creamy Caesar dressing on the side, croutons and Parmesan cheese.$5.00
Small Garden Salad
A mix of greens with tomatoes cucumbers and tomatoes. Served with your choice of dressing$4.50
Allison's Acres Cobb Salad
Crisp romaine lettuce with chopped hard-boiled eggs, bacon, avocado, gorgonzola, diced tomatoes, grilled chicken, and chunky blue cheese dressing.$18.00
Jersey Shore Flounder Reuben
Lightly fried flounder served with Baja Slaw, Swiss cheese, and Thousand Island on grilled marble rye bread. Served with French fries$19.00
Mahi Reuben
Pan seared mahi mahi, Baja slaw, Swiss cheese, thousand island dressing, grilled marble rye bread$19.00
Summer Chicken Sandwich
grilled all-natural chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, Swiss cheese, sautéed onions, garlic aioli, brioche bun, fries$18.00
Pirate's Mahi Sandwich
Blacken grilled Mahi Mahi on a gourmet bun with dijon aioli, lettuce and tomato. served with french fries$19.00
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
* oz grilled all natural chicken breast served on a gourmet bun with lettuce and tomato. Includes fries$12.00
Crab Melt
$32.00
Crab Cake Sandwich
Pan seared crab cake on a gourmet bun with lettuce and tomato choice of tarter cocktail sauce. Includes fries$25.00
Shipyard Cod Sandwich
$19.00
Hen House Chicken Sandwich
$16.00
Po Boy Wam Bam Sandwich
$19.00
Prime Rib Cheesesteak
$22.00
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Our own slow smoked pulled pork on a gourmet bun. Includes fries$15.00
Petite Crab Balls
10 petite fried crab balls. Served with a key lime remoulade.$16.00
Scampi Parmesan Wings
$14.00
Smothered Pork Tomahawk
grilled pork tomahawk with fried mushrooms, onions and mozzarella cheese. Includes. Choice of salad and one side dish$31.00
Dragonfruit Halibut
Grilled Halibut topped with a dragonfruit and kiwi salsa. Includes Choice of salad and one side$38.00
NY Strip Steak & Fried Shrimp
6 oz choice ranch steak served with 4 medium fried shrimp$45.00
Blacken Mahi Bowl
Grilled blacken Mahi Mahi over a bed of our island rice and topped with mangos . Includes choice of salad$22.00
Mad Mutz Hottie Mozzarella Sticks
$12.00
Pulled Pork Mac n Cheese
Creamy cooper mac & cheese topped with our in-house smoked pulled pork (no sides). Includes choice of a garden or Caesar salad$22.00