Rock Springs Cafe

Order type selection

*PIES WHOLE

Apple Crumb

Tender baked apples under a buttery, golden crumb topping. No top crust — just that crispy, sweet crumble.
$27.95

Apple Pie

Granny Smith and Honeycrisp apples baked between two layers of our flaky, golden crust. The American classic.
$27.95

Banana

Fresh sliced bananas folded into rich cream filling, topped with house-made whipped cream.
$27.95

Blackberry

Plump blackberries baked into a sweet, jammy filling under our flaky double crust.
$28.95

Blueberry

Sweet blueberries in a juicy filling baked between two flaky, golden crusts.
$27.95

Blueberry Crumb

Sweet blueberry filling under our buttery, toasted crumb topping.
$27.95

Bourbon Pecan

Our classic pecan pie with a splash of Jack Daniel's baked right into the filling. A best seller.
$28.95

Cherry

Sour cherries with a touch of almond extract, baked under our flaky crust with a heart cutout on top.
$27.95

Cherry Crumb

Sweet cherry filling under our buttery, toasted crumb topping.
$27.95

Chocolate Cherry

Rich chocolate cream layered with cherries — a chocolate-covered cherry in pie form.
$28.95

Chocolate

A rich, velvety chocolate cream filling topped with house-made whipped cream.
$27.95

Coconut

Creamy coconut custard topped with toasted coconut and house-made whipped cream.
$27.95

Key Lime

Tart Key lime filling made with real Key lime juice and zest, topped with sweet whipped cream.
$28.95

Lemon Meringue

Bright lemon custard topped with light, golden meringue. Special order in summer.
$27.95

Mixed Berry

Blackberries, raspberries, and blueberries baked under our buttery crumb topping.
$27.95

Peach

*Special Order* Order must be placed 3 days in advance! Fresh, fragrant peaches baked between two layers of our flaky golden crust.
$28.95

Peach Crumb

Juicy peaches under a buttery, sugar-topped crumble.
$28.95

Pecan

Arizona pecans in a rich, gooey filling with a crisp top and flaky crust. A holiday favorite.
$27.95

Rhubarb

*Special Order* Order must be placed 3 days in advance! Tender, tart rhubarb baked under our toasted crumb topping.
$28.95

Strawberry Rhubarb

Tart rhubarb and juicy strawberries under our toasted crumb topping.
$29.95

Sugar Free Apple

Our classic apple crumb pie made without added sugar. Same buttery crumb, lighter on the sweetness.
$27.95

Tennessee Lemon

A Southern-style lemon pie with a tangy, custardy filling and a flaky crust.
$27.95

PIES HALF

Strawberry Rhubarb Half

A half-size pie, perfect for about 3 generous slices. Tart rhubarb and juicy strawberries under our toasted crumb topping.
$15.95

Apple Crumb Half

A half-size pie, perfect for about 3 generous slices. Tender baked apples under a buttery, golden crumb topping.
$15.95

Bourbon Pecan Half

A half-size pie, perfect for about 3 generous slices. Our classic pecan pie with a splash of Jack Daniel's baked right into the filling.
$15.95

Mixed Berry Half

A half-size pie, perfect for about 3 generous slices. Blackberries, raspberries, and blueberries baked under our buttery crumb topping.
$15.95

Cherry Crumb Half

A half-size pie, perfect for about 3 generous slices. Sweet cherry filling under our buttery, toasted crumb topping.
$15.95

Pumpkin Half

A half-size pie, perfect for about 3 generous slices. Classic spiced pumpkin pie filling in our flaky golden crust.
$15.95