I Want That Yummy logo image

I Want That Yummy


Our Nearly Famous Truffles

Celebrate National Candy Month with a few of our Nearly Famous Treats

Salted Caramel

Topped with generous amounts of dark chocolate and sea salt, our Nearly Famous Caramels are designed to leave a lasting impression.

Salted Caramel

Mint

A minty chocolate center awaits under a sea of green deliciousness.

Mint

Very Vanilla

With a white chocolate coating and your choice of colored sugar, it's a fun way to get your delicious on.

Very Vanilla

S'mores

No campfire required to enjoy this mix of graham crackers, marshmallow and chocolate.

S'mores

Oreo

Our take on the classic cookie ... smiles guaranteed, milk optional.

Oreo

Marshmallow

A soft, fluffy cloud of decadence covered in milk chocolate.

Marshmallow

Mix and Match

You pick the flavors and we'll do the rest. What will your smile taste like?

Mix and Match

Our Nearly Famous Bars

Peanut Butter Bars

Our homemade peanut butter is covered with semi-sweet chocolate and graham cracker dust to create an unforgettable bite of WOW!!!

Peanut Butter Bars

Lemon Bars

For the serious citrus lover, we've got a luscious lemon topping on a graham cracker crust ready to make your day.

Lemon Bars

Chocolate Brownies

The timeless original hand crafted for your enjoyment.

Chocolate Brownies

Our Nearly Famous Breads

Asiago

With it's unmistakable aroma and distinct flavor, this is sure to be a welcome addition to any table.

$15.00

Asiago

Cheddar Cheese

For the Wisconsinite in us all, there's a healthy dose of cheddar both inside and out that comes through in every bite.

$15.00

Cheddar Cheese

Fiesta

Mexican blend cheese, red pepper flakes and garlic combine for a fiesta of flavor. Ole!

$15.00

Fiesta

No Added Sugar

Homemade Peanut Butter - 8 Oz.

Honey roasted peanuts, a touch of oil and a dollop of honey. Simplicity never tasted so good.

$10.00

Homemade Peanut Butter - 8 Oz.

Keto Truffles

You asked, we listened and keto devotees everywhere can now enjoy this combination of dark chocolate, avocado and vanilla as their grab and go reward.

Keto Truffles

Cinnamon Raisin (Dozen)

We start with a great combo, add a few oats, and VOILA, a delightfully decadent bite with no added sugar and no artificial sweeteners.

$15.00

Cinnamon Raisin (Dozen)

Cherry Almond (Dozen)

Dried cherries and almonds combine for a delightfully unique grab and go snack.

$15.00

Cherry Almond (Dozen)

Cocoa Almond (Dozen)

Packed with dates, almonds and a touch of peanut butter, this grab and go goody is a perfect pick-me-up morning, noon or night.

$15.00

Cocoa Almond (Dozen)

PB & Cranberry (Dozen)

You'll be tempted to eat more than one and with no added sugar, you absolutely can!!!

$15.00

PB & Cranberry (Dozen)

Energy Bites (Mix & Match)

Enjoy the decadence of a Nearly Famous Treat with No Added Sugar and No Artificial Sweeteners.

Energy Bites  (Mix & Match)

Breakfast

Coffee Cake

A moist flavorful cake is topped with our homemade brown sugar and a dash of cinnamon. Your morning starts here.

$15.00

Coffee Cake

Blueberry Muffins

Our take on the all-time favorite is packed with blueberries and then more blueberries to create a delightfully indulgent treat (did we mention there's extra blueberries?)

Blueberry Muffins

Cinnamon Roll Loaf

Our take on the breakfast classic has all the flavors you love under that unforgettably delightful icing. YUM!

Cinnamon Roll Loaf

Lemon Muffins

For a little bit of sunshine to start your morning, there's a good dose of citrus under a sugar crumb topping that will get your smile off and running.

Lemon Muffins

Chocolate Muffins

Semi-sweet chunks topping semi-sweet chocolate and cocoa powder. Getting up was never so easy.

Chocolate Muffins