Lefty’s Righteous Bagels

Order type selection

Bagel & Schmear

Bagel & Schmear

Try one! Try them all! Mix and match your favorite bagel and schmear flavors. All of our schmears are served in 2oz. containers on the side so you can add as much as YOU like!
$5.20

Bagel Sandwiches

Our sandwich ingredients have been crafted to pair well together. We suggest ordering them as we've built them, but you can leave some things off...if you really want to.

The Eggy Vedder

Folded eggs, cheese, chipotle mayo, bacon, arugula
$13.75

The Moira Rose

Folded eggs, gouda cheese, shaved ham, dijon mustard mayo, roasted garlic & chive cream cheese, arugula
$14.75

The Billy Corgan

Nova lox, pickled red onion, lemon dill cream cheese, and capers.
$16.75

The Larry Bird

Turkey pastrami, provolone cheese, green goddess drizzle, roasted garlic & chive cream cheese, arugula
$16.75

The Jerry Garcia

Garlic roasted portabella mushrooms, havarti cheese, sun-dried tomato cream cheese, arugula
$13.75

The Ned Flanders

Nova, lox, and plain cream cheese
$12.25

Deli Salad Sandwich

4oz of any of our deli salads, arugula (Options: pesto chicken, curried chickpea (V), tuna)
$10.50

Bag of Bagels

Order a 1/2 or full dozen and we'll throw an extra bagel in the bag! Try pairing them with our 8oz. schmears for the full LRB experience.

LRB Whole

Choose your favorites and make sure you select the extra one on us...a Lefty's Whole is THIRTEEN bagels!
$29.75

LRB Half

Choose your favorites and make sure you select the extra one on us...a Lefty's Half is SEVEN bagels!
$16.50

Schmears

2oz Schmear

8oz Schmear

Solo Bagel

Just the bagel. Not sliced, not toasted. A "come as you are" order.

Solo Bagel

$3.25

Prepared Foods

4oz Packaged Lox

Take home a 4oz. package of delicious Nova Lox to add to any bagel and schmear.
$6.25

8oz Packaged Lox

Take home a 8oz. package of delicious Nova Lox to add to any bagel and schmear.
$12.50

Yogurt Parfait

A delicious combination of yogurt, housemade granola, berry compote, and honey.
$5.75

Curried Chickpea Salad

$6.99

Chicken Pesto Salad

$6.99

Tuna Salad

$6.99

Bialy

Our delicious bialy is like a bagel’s cooler, less high-maintenance cousin—chewy, golden, and rocking a savory filled center instead of a hole. It skips the boil, keeps things tender, and makes butter or cream cheese feel like they’ve hit the jackpot.

Chef's Special Bialy

$6.25

Onion Poppyseed Bialy

$6.25

Drip Coffee

Drip Coffee

Check out our latest house roast. We might just be brewing something new. Available in 12oz, 16oz, and 20oz sizes.

Red Eye

Drip coffee with a shot of espresso. Available in 12oz, 16oz, and 20oz sizes.

Cafe Au Lait

Espresso Drinks

Try our selection of barista drinks! Our coffee beans are provided by Magnifico Coffee Roasters, a family-owned, Chicago-based roastery.

Latte

Espresso shots and milk. Available in 12oz, 16oz, and 20oz sizes.

Americano

Espresso shots and water. Available in 12oz, 16oz, and 20oz sizes.

Cappuccino

Macchiato 4oz

Two shots of espresso and a dollop of milk foam.
$4.25

Cortado 4oz

Two shots of espresso and 2 ounces of steamed milk.
$4.75

Flat White 6oz

$5.00

Single Espresso

One shot of espresso.
$3.00

Double Espresso

Two shots of espresso.
$4.00

Lemonade

Lemonade

$3.50

Other Hot Drinks

Hot Chocolate

Chocolate syrup, vanilla syrup, and steamed milk. Available in 12oz, 16oz, and 20oz sizes.

Kids Hot Chocolate

Kids version of the hot chocolate. Chocolate syrup, vanilla syrup, and steamed milk at kids temperature.
$2.75

Steamers

Steamed milk...because maybe you don't need the caffeine but you still want the flavor. Available in 12oz, 16oz, and 20oz sizes.

Tea Drinks

Chai

Chai and milk (tea latte). Available in 12oz, 16oz, and 20oz sizes.

London Fog

Earl Grey tea, milk, and vanilla syrup. Available in 12oz, 16oz, and 20oz sizes.

Matcha

Matcha (finely ground green tea) and milk. Available in 12oz, 16oz, and 20oz sizes.

Iced Tea

$3.50

Steeped Tea

Rotating selection of Tazo tea flavors. Available in 12oz, 16oz, and 20oz sizes.